MISSISSIPPI HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES
WEEKLY SUMMARY REPORT FOR WEEK ENDING APRIL 16, 2004
JACKSON, Miss. -- The upward revision of the FY 2005 revenue estimate, the
long-awaited passage of comprehensive Voter I.D., and the continuing
struggle to bring tort reform to a floor vote in the House, all highlighted
the 15th week of the 2004 Regular Session.
The improving economy led the Joint
Legislative Budget Committee this week to revise upward the official
estimate of state revenues for the coming 2005 fiscal year beginning July 1,
2004. The 14-member committee, comprised of seven House members and seven
Senators, heard from state fiscal experts that the economy is stronger now
than when the FY 2005 revenue estimate was first established last Fall. On
the strength of this expert opinion, the committee voted to add $44 million
to revenues available for FY 2005 appropriations, bringing the General Fund
budget to a total of $3.655 billion. The state’s overall budget, including
Federal funds and special funds created through agency fees, special taxes
(such as fuel taxes) and other means, will be over $11 billion.
Governor Haley Barbour urged
the Legislature to use all of the newly-found $44 million
to help fund the K-12
education budget: "Thanks to a strong economy, we will be able to boost
funding for education," said the governor. "This is not ‘funny money.’ This
is a projection set by our state experts, and not by politicians."
A major positive event this week in the House
was the passage of
HB 1827 to require voter identification at the polls in every election.
Persons born before January 1, 1940, would be exempted from the proposed new
law. Prospective voters may use any number of forms, such as a driver’s
license and even a bank statement, in order to identify themselves to poll
workers. If the voter whose name appears on the rolls is unable to produce a
valid I.D., he or she nonetheless may vote if they first sign a sworn
statement as to their identity. Any person falsely swearing to an identity
for purposes of voting can be prosecuted as a felon and be fined up to
$5,000, sentenced to a year in jail, or both. HB 1827 also provides that
certain first-time convicts of non-violent crimes who have completed their
sentences and paid their fines and all restitution may be re-enfranchised to
vote upon their release. The bill also requires Circuit Clerks to issue all
voters a registration card by January 1, 2007. The new Voter I.D. provisions
contained within HB 1827 will go into effect on January 1, 2005, if the
United States Department of Justice pre-clears the legislation as envisioned
by the Federal Voting Rights Act.
Tort reform continues as an issue of great
contention in the Legislature. On Wednesday evening,
Rep. Ed Blackmon
(D–Canton) exercised his prerogative and declined to bring
SB 2763, which had passed in a
much weakened form out of the Judiciary A committee which he chairs, to
the House floor for consideration. Had Chairman Blackmon called the bill up
for floor debate, the bill likely would have been strengthened through
amendments offered by tort reform proponents -- something Rep. Blackmon
apparently was unwilling to chance. Because it was known that the bill would
die if not acted upon by midnight, many members of the House resisted the
routine motion to adjourn for the day, because adjournment necessarily would
kill the bill. A little after 8:00 p.m., the House voted to adjourn by the
extraordinarily close tally of 61-58, seen by many observers as the first
real tort reform vote on the House floor this year. Lauderdale County
Representatives casting a "no" vote on adjournment included
Rep. Eric
Robinson (R–Quitman),
Rep. Greg Snowden
(R–Meridian), and Rep.
Steve Horne (R–Meridian). With adjournment, SB 2763 died for the
Session.
A second tort reform measure,
HB 1323, a House banking bill in which the Senate had inserted a
strong tort reform package similar to the original (not weakened)
SB 2763, met with a highly unusual fate when the bill was returned to
the House for concurrence or nonconcurrence. Typically, the bill would have
been placed on the House concurrence calendar and assigned to
Rep. Danny Guice
(R–Gulfport), the Chairman of the House Banking committee which had
originally handled the bill in the House. However, Rep. Guice, a tort reform
supporter, had made it known that he intended to move that the House concur
(accept) the Senate additions to HB 1323, and had a majority of the House
agreed, as most expected, the bill with its strong tort reform provisions
would have gone straight to the governor. Unwilling for the full House
membership to have a vote on whether simply to concur on HB 1323,
Speaker Billy McCoy
(D–Rienzi) took the unusual step of reassigning the bill to
Rep. Ed Blackmon
(D–Canton), who now, rather than Rep. Guice, will make the decision as to
whether to make a motion that the House concur or invite conference on HB
1323 (considered unlikely, because making either motion would give the full
House membership a vote), or, as is most probable, simply to allow the bill
to die on the House calendar by failing to call it up prior to the April 29
deadline for concurrence or nonconcurrence. If HB 1323 dies, there will be
no further opportunity for tort reform in the 2004 Regular Session unless
the House and Senate suspend the rules (2/3 vote being required) and bring
up a new bill after the deadline, as was done last week in the successful
effort to revive Voter I.D. after the deadlines otherwise had passed.
Nothing is ever "dead, dead, dead" until the Legislature adjourns sine
die and goes home, but the prospects of obtaining a floor vote on tort
reform in the 2004 Regular Session appeared very dim at the end of the week.
Governor Barbour has all but vowed to call the Legislature back this summer
in a special session to deal with tort reform if no progress is made during
the Regular Session.
A remarkable debate occurred on Tuesday morning relating to
House Resolution 51,
brought forward by the House Rules Committee, chaired by
Rep. Joe Warren
(D–Mount Olive). Unlike a bill, a resolution has no force of law, but simply
is an expression of the consensus of the House of Representatives on a
particular subject. HR 51, authored by
Rep.
Bennett Malone (D–Carthage), urges
Congress to call for an amendment to the Constitution of the United States
to provide as follows: "Neither the Supreme Court nor any inferior
court of the United States shall have the power to instruct or to order a
state or political subdivision thereof, or an official of such a state or
political subdivision, to levy or increase taxes." This proposed
"Judicial Taxation" resolution was debated heatedly for more than an hour,
with liberal members of the House bemoaning the very idea that the
Constitution be amended so as to restrain the power of an unelected
judiciary to usurp the authority of elected representatives to make taxing
decisions. In the end, however, HR 51 passed handily, putting the
Mississippi House of Representatives on record as favoring a constitutional
amendment to limit the power of the courts to order states to impose taxes
as a remedy to cure such various and sundry ills as the courts may choose to
identify.
Political posturing over the funding of K-12 education led to much
unnecessary heartache for many Mississippi teachers this week. April 15 was
the statutory deadline for school districts to notify teachers of
nonemployment decisions for the upcoming school year. Since 2004 is the
first year of a new governor’s term, the Legislative session this year is
125 days, and will not end until the first week of May. Given the fact that
the state budget typically is finalized at the end of the session, during
the last week thereof, the Senate had proposed to extend to May 15 the
deadline for districts to give nonemployment notifications. Unfortunately,
however, the House leadership made the politically expedient decision to
refuse to allow House members to vote on whether to extend the deadline,
preferring to "keep the pressure on" the Senate to hastily adopt the House’s
own fiscally-questionable education funding plan. (Which the Senate, to its
credit, determined Thursday not to do, passing its own budget instead, which
will put the education budget into a conference committee, where such
budgets normally are finalized in due course).
House inaction on
HB 657, as sent back from the Senate
with language which would have extended the school districts' statutory
teacher nonrenewal notification deadline to May 15, led directly to many
teachers unnecessarily receiving "pink slips" from some school
administrators concerned that K-12 funding will not eventually be
forthcoming. In actuality, however, the educational budgeting process is
taking its normal and regular course, and the House and Senate conferees are
expected to craft an acceptable budget on schedule in early May which will
fund K-12 education, always the Legislature’s top funding priority, to the
very highest levels possible within the state’s means.
Governor Barbour
and Lieutenant Governor
Tuck, flanked by legislators of both parties from both the Senate and
the House, held a joint press conference Wednesday afternoon to
denounce the
political scare tactics employed by those who have fostered apprehension
and anguish among Mississippi educators through the utilization of a popular
"pro education" mantra in an effort to avoid making difficult decisions on
the state budget as a whole. "Teachers should not be used as political
pawns, and they should not be the first place to look to for cost-savings,"
said Governor Barbour. "Instead of scaring our teachers with ‘pink’,
Mississippi should be focused on getting out of the ‘red’," he said.
On Friday morning,
SB 3177 was brought to
the House floor from the Ways and Means Committee.
Rep.
Greg Snowden (R–Meridian) offered an
amendment which would have created a back-to-school sales tax "holiday"
during the first weekend in August. The
Snowden amendment would have exempted from sales tax articles of
clothing and footwear priced at less than $100 from 12:01 a.m. on the first
Friday in August through 12:00 midnight on the following Saturday.
Designed mainly to provide families with a much-needed tax break to assist
in the purchase of school clothes (but available to all citizens regardless
of age or circumstance), the sales tax "holiday" also would been a powerful
retail marketing tool to entice out-of-state shoppers and would have been
particularly beneficial to retail merchants in the peripheral areas of the
state, such as Meridian, Southaven, Vicksburg, Greenville, Columbus, and
along the Gulf Coast.
Rep.
Erik Fleming (D–Jackson) joined the
bipartisan support for the Snowden amendment, correctly pointing out in the
floor debate that the sales tax "holiday" would be particularly helpful to
needy families with school-aged children. Many states have adopted
such sales tax "holidays" with minimal negative impact upon overall state
revenues, in part because shoppers (many of whom are enticed from
out-of-state) invariably use their tax savings to purchase additional,
non-exempt items, and also because higher gross sales inevitably lead to
greater employment and more income taxes eventually paid into state coffers.
Nevertheless, continuing concerns about tight revenues in Mississippi during
the current budgetary process undoubtedly led to the defeat of the
Snowden amendment by a close vote of 54 to 63, but SB 3177 has been held
on a motion to reconsider, and there is at least a chance the House may
reconsider and adopt the sales tax "holiday" for Mississippi when it
reconvenes early next week.
Among the bills passed in the House this week
was an amended version of
SB 2892, which increases various fees in order to set up a method of
funding drug courts statewide, and also to partially fund the eight
Department of Mental Health crisis intervention centers around the state,
most of which have been constructed, but only one of which (near Corinth)
presently is staffed. The House also approved
SB 2370, limiting potentially misleading advertisements for legal
services by notaries public; SB 2446, awarding honorary high school diplomas
to Vietnam War veterans who dropped out to fight in the war; and SB 2727,
nominating the Pascagoula River and Bear Creek as scenic streams, part of an
ongoing state conservation program.
The House observed a moment of silence on
Tuesday to honor a Lauderdale County hero, U.S. Marine Christopher Dale
Mabry, of Clarkdale, who was killed in action in Iraq on April 7. The House
also honored retiring Mississippi Area Methodist Bishop Kenneth L. Carder
for his service to the state, and passed various commending resolutions
honoring individuals and groups such as Viking Range CEO Fred Carl Jr., of
Greenwood, football legend and East Mississippi Community College coach Tom
Goode, and award winning actress Tonea Stewart, of Greenwood. The House will
have a brief ceremony in the chamber on Tuesday, April 20, to honor all the
Mississippi National Guard units that have been activated during the war
against terrorism, and urging Mississippians to send greetings and thanks to
all of her brave warriors in the cause of freedom.
Late last week, the full House of
Representatives approved bills on several subjects that have been at the
forefront of the session almost since it started. Among these were
SB 2063, allowing the state to contract with private companies to
construct toll roads in areas of high need, such as on the Gulf Coast with a
connecting road between state ports;
SB 2853 to allow the drilling for natural gas in the Mississippi Sound,
with a prohibition in the area closest to Alabama waters for environmental
reasons, and with an amendment that mandates counties receiving severance
taxes must reduce local property taxes by an amount equal to 50 percent of
the tax proceeds; and
SB 2436, to include language favorable to seniors and the disabled in
the bill that spells out how the state’s massive Medicaid program is to be
operated.
Representative Greg Snowden (R––Meridian) maintains a legislative web
site to aid constituents and other interested persons in obtaining
information about state government. The web site address is
www.gregsnowden.com. Rep. Snowden may be reached by e-mail at greg@gregsnowden.com,
or by telephone at 601-693-5700 (Meridian office) or 601-527-5350 (cell
phone –– a local call from anywhere within Mississippi).
EDITORIAL NOTE: Most of the facts and
much of the organization of the above summary is due to the fine work of
Mac Gordon, of the House Information Office. However, although Mr. Gordon
provides this information weekly to all House members, each member has the
privilege of using it however he or she sees fit. Rep. Snowden has taken
the liberty to re-write much of the standard summary, and to include his
own comments and expressions of opinion. Accordingly, while Rep. Snowden
gratefully acknowledges the work of the House Information Office in
organizing and supplying reliable and timely information as to the
workings of the House, all comment and all opinion contained in this
summary is that of Rep. Snowden alone, and not that of Mr. Gordon or any
other staff employee of the House of Representatives.
|