JACKSON, Miss. -- The Legislature this week adopted an historic and
unprecedented plan to finance the state's public education system ahead of
all other government-funded activities.
The education appropriations conference reports (HB 1033 and SB 2678)
received approval Friday in both the full House and Senate at the end of the
fourth week of the 2003 legislative session. The compromise measure was
agreed upon by House and Senate negotiators after a week of discussions in
conference committee. The governor has announced that he plans to sign the
measures into law at a ceremony on Tuesday.
The education measure also includes the funding necessary to retain the
services of Barry Rhoads, a military base-closure consultant who has
assisted Meridian and other Mississippi military communities in past BRAC
rounds, another of which Congress has scheduled for 2005. The state’s
military communities had been surprised and alarmed in November when
Governor Musgrove fired Rhoads and replaced him with a Democratic party
operative possessing comparatively little base closure experience.
Nevertheless, Musgrove pleased military communities representatives around
the state Friday when he promised not to veto this new funding measure,
which was tacked onto the massive education bill. Barry Rhoads, therefore,
will remain "on board" as the state gears up to resist anticipated new
Federal efforts to close some of Mississippi’s military bases.
But the massive "up-front" funding of educational needs was the week’s
big story at the Capitol. Historically, education spending has been handled
near the end of each session along with other state agencies, but this year
(an election year) the Legislature chose to cement education as it’s top
priority with the early funding measure. The bill would allocate about $236
million in additional money over and above original Legislative
Budget committee recommendations for public education for FY 2004. The state
General Fund budget for FY 2004 will be approximately $3.5 billion, and
educational spending alone will top $2.1 billion, or some 62 percent of the
total. The two education appropriations conference reports approved by the
Legislature Friday (HB 1033 and SB 2678) together provide $142 million
additional for K-12, $23.5 million additional for community
colleges, and $70 million additional for higher education, all over
and above what budget writers originally had recommended in November.
To give some perspective to the magnitude of this week’s legislative
action, consider the complaints frequently voiced to the effect that
Mississippi should spend more money on education and less on prisons. The
Legislative Budget committee recommended in November that the total
Corrections (i.e., prisons) budget for FY 2004 be only $234 million, or less
than 7% of the General Fund budget, which total is less than the
increase ($236 million) added for education this week over and above
original Legislative Budget committee recommendations. Indeed, of all
the other expenditures made by the state from the General Fund budget, the
total from only two areas, Debt Service and Medicaid (at
approximately $246 million each) exceed the increase ($236 million)
over and above original recommendations added to education this week by the
Legislature. Not only is education the obvious number one priority of the
Legislature, it is so far ahead of whatever is number two to make any
comparison irrelevant.
Educational leaders, naturally, were very pleased with this week’s
action. Tom Layzell, the state's higher education chief, soon to move to a
similar post in Kentucky, called the plan "unprecedented action" by the
Legislature in an appearance before the House Appropriations Committee.
Alcorn State University President Clinton Bristow Jr. said it "sends the
message nationally that we are moving forward in Mississippi" and that it
tells "our professors to stay home." University of Mississippi Chancellor
Robert Khayat said the bill "makes the statement that education is critical
to the development of Mississippi." University of Mississippi Medical Center
Vice Chancellor Wallace Conerly, M.D., whose facility has been hit hard by
budget cuts in recent years, said the current proposal could be the "saving
grace" for the state's only teaching hospital.
Mississippi's historically low out-of-state tuition rate has been on the
rise in recent years, one official noted. Once the lowest in the U.S., the
rate has been increased by 44 percent in recent years.
The massive infusion of money into education for FY 2004 largely is from
"one time monies" that will not be available in future years. That means
that unless the economy picks up dramatically and revenues improve
significantly, budget writers in future sessions will face very difficult
decisions. House Speaker Tim Ford (D–Baldwyn), who himself is retiring at
the end of this session, this week flatly predicted that the Legislature
will be forced to raise taxes next year. Quoted in the Clarion-Ledger,
Ford said: "They can either have a tremendous cut next year or I think
you're going to be looking at a combination of taxes . . . I don't think
that the economy can pick up fast enough to take care of it." And, speaking
from the House floor on Friday, Education Committee Chairman Joe Warren,
(D–Mount Olive) agreed: "Unless there is a really big upturn in the economy,
you're going to be faced with either raising some money or making very
drastic cuts."
Clearly, the 2004 Regular Session of the Legislature, which will feature
a new Speaker, many new members of the House and Senate, and perhaps a new
Governor and Lieutenant Governor, already is shaping up as a battle royale
on the question of new and additional taxes for Mississippi.
A very controversial item of debate on the floor of the House this week
related to HB 825, which directed that the state's estimated $104 million
2003 payment from the tobacco settlement be diverted from the trust fund and
spent to help pay for various state-funded medical programs. When the
tobacco trust fund was established a few years ago, the Legislature pledged
not to touch the principal, but rather would spend the earnings on needed
health-care programs. But when budget times got hard, as was the case last
year as well as this year, Legislative leaders considered it necessary to
scoop up the annual tobacco payment and spend it in the budget before the
money ever makes it into the "trust" fund. Proponents of the tobacco
diversions have characterized this process as "borrowing money from
ourselves," but the events of this week reveal that the term "borrowing" is
a misnomer, because there evidently is no serious intention ever to pay the
diverted money back into the trust fund.
Rep. Jim Ellington (R–Jackson) offered a floor amendment to HB 825 which
would have required the money be paid back into the trust fund in annual
installments beginning in FY 2006. As Ellington told the House, the
amendment would make the diversion a "true loan" and would obligate the
Legislature to put back the money it is now forced to take out to meet the
current budget emergency. Ellington warned members that Mississippi should
not follow the sad example of Tennessee, which essentially has already spent
it’s tobacco monies to shore up the state budget. But, in a very
illuminating floor debate, it became clear that the proponents of the
tobacco diversion do not consider replenishment of the trust fund to have
much priority; indeed, Rep. George Flaggs (D–Vicksburg) admitted as much and
said that the money should not be paid back unless and until the state meets
a very optimistic 5 percent growth requirement contained within the original
HB 825. Ellington’s amendment, supported by most Republicans and many
fiscally conservative Democrats, failed by a vote of 50 to 70. HB 825,
allowing the diversion with no realistic mechanism for repayment,
subsequently passed the House by a vote of 96 to 25.
In addition to the historic floor action this week, House committees
passed out dozens of bills that will now go before the full House of
Representatives for consideration. The deadline for committee action on all
general (non-revenue) bills and constitutional amendments is Tuesday,
February 4 in the chamber of origin, with Thursday, February 13 the deadline
for original floor action on the bills that survived committee action.
Several public hearings were held at the Capitol this week by House
committees and other groups. They explored safety aspects of police
pursuits, uninsured motorist insurance coverage, high salaries at some state
agencies and several anti-smoking bills before the Legislature.
Three medical experts testified to the alleged harmful effects of
second-hand smoke, which one witness said is a leading cause of 53,000
deaths in the U.S. each year. Testimony was presented that said even the
newest ventilation technology available is incapable of removing all
second-hand smoke and its toxic components from the air. "Only laws that
prohibit smoking in indoor environments can guarantee safe levels of
exposure to second-hand smoke," according to this testimony.
Bills have been proposed that would ban smoking in all public places,
another to ban smoking in restaurants, and another would limit smoking to
the enclosed bar areas of restaurants. Another proposal would substantially
raise the excise tax on tobacco products.
Yet another group pushed this week for a new law to make not wearing a
seat belt a primary traffic offense. Under current law, although seat belt
use is mandatory, it is a secondary offense, and law officers may not stop a
motorist for the sole purpose of checking seat belt usage. Any citation for
failure to wear a seat belt must be issued in association with another
(primary) offense. The Department of Public Safety told those at the hearing
that three-fourths of all drivers killed in the state in recent times were
not wearing seat belts.
Here are some other bills that were passed out of committee and sent on
to the full House:
> HB 1146 which would bring the state into full compliance with the
federal "Help America Vote Act," and also help deliver an estimated $34
million to Mississippi to pay for instituting voting reforms considered
desirable in the wake of problems in the 2000 presidential election. The
full House has not yet considered this measure.
> HB 454 to provide for a civil fine of $100 for individual members of a
public body (city councils, boards of supervisors, school boards, etc.) who
willfully violate the provisions of the state's Open Meetings Law. Current
law contains no "teeth" and HB 454 is intended as an incentive for officials
to obey the law when it comes to public access to public meetings. This bill
later passed the full House.
> HB 583 making teleconferences and other video meetings of public bodies
conform with the Open Meetings Law. This bill also subsequently passed the
full House.
> HB 646 requiring new applicants for physician licenses to be
fingerprinted.
> HB 1027 to create drug courts statewide passed the Judiciary 'A'
Committee. The courts have been highly successful in turning around addicts
and in saving the state money.
> HB 1032 to establish a state certification program for therapeutic
riding instructors passed the Public Health and Welfare Committee and the
full House. The state Extension Service would provide the training.
> HB 800 to require charter boat captains to participate in a
DOT-approved random drug testing program and proof of liability insurance.
> HB 63 to allow universities and two-year colleges to offer certain
gaming-related courses.
> HB 1440 would allow the state to buy a hangar at Jackson International
Airport from the struggling WorldCom Inc. to expand state airplane storage
capability.
> HB 1120 would create a criminal offense of killing or injuring a public
service animal. Fines could range up to $5,000 and jail sentences to five
years.
> The House Transportation Committee amended a bill to designate a
portion of State Highway 1 in the Delta as the "C.B. (Buddie) Newman
Memorial Highway" in honor of the late speaker of the House of
Representatives. Speaker Newman died in 2002.